
Guilty in the Womb: Herod, Pharaoh, and the New Ideology of the Pre-emptive Sword
❧ ✦ ❧
Introduction: A Voice Heard in Ramah—Again
Every December, between the carols and the candlelight, the Church remembers a scene that seems to belong to another world. A frightened and furious king, told by foreign astrologers that a rival “King of the Jews” has been born, sends soldiers into a small Judean village with orders to kill every boy two years old and under. Matthew records it in three verses, then reaches back six centuries to the prophet Jeremiah for words big enough to carry the grief: Rachel weeping for her children, refusing to be comforted, “because they are not.”
We comfort ourselves that such things belong to the age of Herods and Pharaohs. Then, in November 2026, a report surfaced that a special education teacher at Clopper Mill Elementary School in Germantown, Maryland, had written on Facebook that the world needs fewer men, that mothers should “stop giving birth” to boys, and that she herself would abort a son rather than “give birth to my own oppressor.” Her words were not issued from a throne. They came from a keyboard. But the moral logic beneath them is older than Bethlehem: a whole class of children marked for removal because of what some of them might one day become.
This essay examines that report carefully and from a traditional Christian perspective. It sets the reported statements beside the Massacre of the Innocents, weighs the historical evidence for that massacre, and asks what Scripture says about a heart that can look at an unborn son and see only an enemy. It closes, as the Bible itself closes every exposure of darkness, with a call both to resist evil and to proclaim the One who overcomes it.
❧ ✦ ❧
The Report: What Was Said, and By Whom
The Source Trail
The story reached a wide audience through a November 21, 2026, American Thinker blog post by Eric Utter. Utter did not do original reporting; his piece is commentary built on two earlier reports, chiefly a November 5 investigation by Ethan Barton of the Washington Free Beacon, with additional details from LifeSiteNews. According to the Free Beacon, the teacher, Dana Zentgraf, posted under the Facebook name “Da Graf,” and her earlier comments—including some on the Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) Facebook page—had appeared under her full name.
“It’s your son too. It’s all of them. They are all menace[s] to society and we need to stop giving birth to them.”
— Dana Zentgraf, Facebook post as “Da Graf,” as reported by Ethan Barton, Washington Free Beacon, November 5, 2026
In an October 24 post, according to the same report, she wrote that if she were still of reproductive age, she would learn her baby’s sex through a blood test and abort a male child. She did not, she wrote, want to give birth to “my own oppressor,” adding that the only way out of “this patriarchal hell” is for there to be “less men on this earth.” Another undated post advised mothers that if it is too late to abort, they should raise the boy as though their lives depended on it. On October 30, she reportedly wrote that overthrowing the government, not voting, was “the only answer.”
A Word on Accuracy
A scholar owes his readers precision, especially when the subject is a living person. Three cautions are in order. First, the statements rest on screenshots compiled by the Free Beacon; the account was reportedly deleted after the outlet contacted her, and neither she nor MCPS responded to requests for comment. Second, American Thinker’s headline—that she “says all male babies should be aborted”—sharpens her words somewhat. What she reportedly wrote is that women should stop giving birth to boys, that she would abort her own son, and that the world needs fewer men. The difference is one of degree, not of kind, but honest critics should quote her exactly. Third, nothing in the reporting shows that she said any of this in a classroom or treated any student differently. Parents of the boys in her care are entitled to ask questions; they are not entitled to assume answers the evidence has not given.
With those cautions stated, the reported words are clear enough to examine on their own terms. A woman entrusted with the education of vulnerable children reportedly declared that male children, as a class, are a menace whose births ought to be prevented. That is the claim we must weigh.
❧ ✦ ❧
The Bethlehem Precedent
The Text
“Then Herod, when he saw that he was mocked of the wise men, was exceeding wroth, and sent forth, and slew all the children that were in Bethlehem, and in all the coasts thereof, from two years old and under, according to the time which he had diligently enquired of the wise men. Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremy the prophet, saying, In Rama was there a voice heard, lamentation, and weeping, and great mourning, Rachel weeping for her children, and would not be comforted, because they are not.”
— Matthew 2:16–18 (King James Version)
The Greek of verse 16 uses the masculine plural, tous paidas, and the context makes plain that the victims were boys: Herod sought one male child, the newborn king, and killed every male child who might be him. Matthew’s citation of Jeremiah 31:15 is deliberate. In Jeremiah, Rachel—the matriarch whose tomb tradition placed near Bethlehem—mourns the sons of Israel carried into Babylonian exile. Matthew hears her weeping again in the same district, now over sons who will not return at all.
Did It Really Happen?
Critics have long pointed out that Josephus, who devoted extensive attention to Herod, never mentions the massacre. The objection deserves a serious answer, and conservative historians have given one. The late Paul L. Maier, professor of ancient history at Western Michigan University, noted that Bethlehem was a village of perhaps 1,500 people. By his actuarial estimate, it would have held only about two dozen children aged two and under, about half of them girls—meaning roughly a dozen to fifteen boys were killed. Horrific as that is, it is the kind of local atrocity a historian chronicling Herod’s murders of his own wife and sons could easily pass over.
“Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.”
— Paul L. Maier, interview, Desiring God, “Truth or Fiction? Did Herod Really Slaughter Baby Boys in Bethlehem?”
Trent Horn of Catholic Answers adds that ancient historians routinely omit events we know from other sources. Josephus and Tacitus both say nothing of Claudius expelling the Jews from Rome around A.D. 49, an event attested by Suetonius and by Acts 18:2. More importantly, the event fits everything Josephus does tell us about Herod. Josephus records that Herod executed his beloved wife Mariamne, strangled his sons Alexander and Aristobulus, had his heir Antipater killed five days before his own death, and ordered that leading men of Judea be locked in the hippodrome at Jericho and slaughtered when he died, so that the nation would mourn (Antiquities 15.7; 16.11; 17.6–7). The late Roman writer Macrobius preserves a joke attributed to Augustus that it was better to be Herod’s pig than his son.
“Such an act of cruelty perfectly corresponds with Herod’s paranoid and merciless character.”
— Trent Horn, “Is the Massacre of the Holy Innocents Historical?” Catholic Answers Magazine, December 26, 2019
GotQuestions.org notes that demographers place the number of victims between twenty and forty, far below the inflated figures of later legend, and that the Western Church honors them on December 28 as the Holy Innocents. The point is not the size of the grave but the principle of the sword: children killed not for anything they had done but for what one of them might become.
Herod Was Not the First
Herod stands in a line. Pharaoh, fearing the growth of the Hebrews, ordered the midwives to kill every son at birth and then commanded that every newborn boy be thrown into the Nile (Exodus 1:16, 22). Once again the target was male children, and once again the motive was fear of what they might become. Behind both stands the figure John sees in Revelation 12:4: the dragon waiting before the woman in labor, ready to devour her child the moment it is born. Scripture presents the war on the sons not as an occasional political crime but as a recurring move of the ancient enemy of God and man.
❧ ✦ ❧
The Comparison: The Logic of the Pre-emptive Sword
Guilt by Category
Put the two cases side by side, and the parallel is plain. Herod condemned the boys of Bethlehem because one of them might grow up to be a king who threatened his throne. The Maryland teacher, by her own reported words, would condemn her own unborn son because he might grow up to be an “oppressor.” In both cases, a child is assigned the guilt of a projected future. In both cases, sex alone decides the sentence. In both cases, the child has done nothing at all.
Scripture flatly rejects this reasoning. “The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father,” says Ezekiel 18:20, and the Law forbade putting children to death for the sins of their fathers (Deuteronomy 24:16). If God will not hold a son guilty for his own father’s real sins, by what standard could any person hold a baby guilty for the imagined sins of men he will never meet? The idea that a male child is born already implicated in “patriarchal” oppression is a secular doctrine of inherited guilt, and it is more merciless than any version of original sin the Church has taught—because it offers no Redeemer, only removal.
An Honest Distinction
Careful argument also requires stating where the comparison stops. Herod held the sword of state and used it; a dozen or more real children died. Mrs. Zentgraf held a Facebook account. No child has been harmed by her posts, and nothing in the reporting suggests that anyone has acted on them. To blur that difference would be to commit the very injustice we condemn—assigning guilt for deeds not done.
The comparison, then, is not one of body count but of moral logic. And moral logic matters, because deeds grow out of ideas. Jesus located murder first in the heart (Matthew 5:21–22; 15:19). A culture that learns to see unborn children as threats to be managed has already taken the first step down Herod’s road. Indeed, the world has already walked that road in the other direction: sex-selective abortion of girls in parts of Asia has produced tens of millions of “missing women,” and Christians rightly denounced it. The objection is the same now that the target is boys. The Christian case is not pro-male or pro-female; it is pro-image-bearer.
Rachel Weeping—and the Mother Who Would Not
There is one more contrast, and it is the most painful. In Bethlehem, the mothers wept and would not be comforted. Their sons were torn from them against their will. In the reported Facebook posts, the speaker is a woman who says she would not want her son at all. Isaiah asked a question that every age assumed had an obvious answer: “Can a woman forget her sucking child, that she should not have compassion on the son of her womb?” (Isaiah 49:15, KJV). Paul’s list of the marks of a darkened culture includes being “without natural affection” (Romans 1:31, KJV). When the sword is taken up not by a hostile king but in the name of the mother herself, Rachel’s lament takes on a darker tone.
❧ ✦ ❧
The Theology of the Darkened Heart
Dead in Trespasses and Sins
How does a person come to regard a baby boy as an oppressor? Scripture’s answer begins not in Maryland but in Eden. Paul describes all people apart from Christ as “dead in trespasses and sins” (Ephesians 2:1), walking according to the course of this world and the prince of the power of the air. Reformed theologians have called this condition total depravity, or total moral inability—not that every person is as wicked as possible, but that sin has corrupted every faculty, including the reason and the affections.
“Spiritual death signifies not just separation, but a profound incapacity to seek, love, or obey God apart from sovereign grace.”
— Monergism, “Dead in Sin: A Biblical Diagnosis of Spiritual Inability”
Ligonier Ministries summarizes the doctrine in a single line: “We are dead with respect to the things of God.” Wendyl Leslie, writing on Ephesians 2:1–3, identifies the marks of that death as living by worldly standards, following the enemy’s influence, and being ruled by self-centered desire. John Piper, in his 2008 seminar on the doctrines of grace, pressed the point further: the problem is not merely ignorance of the light but hostility toward it.
“Men don’t just choose darkness; men love darkness.”
— John Piper, “Total Depravity & Unconditional Election, Session 4,” Desiring God, March 8, 2008
This doctrine explains how a sentence like “we need to stop giving birth to them” can be written without apparent horror. A darkened mind does not experience its own darkness as darkness. It experiences it as insight, even as liberation. Isaiah pronounced woe on exactly this inversion: “Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness” (Isaiah 5:20, KJV). To call the birth of a son a menace and his absence a deliverance is to rename darkness as light.
The Seared Conscience
Paul warned Timothy that in the latter times some would depart from the faith, “having their conscience seared with a hot iron” (1 Timothy 4:2, KJV). GotQuestions.org compares such a conscience to skin scarred by a branding iron, numbed by “spiritual scar tissue” until it no longer registers pain. John MacArthur, preaching on this text, used the 1984 crash of an Avianca airliner, whose crew silenced the ground-proximity alarm moments before impact, as a picture of what a culture does when it disconnects its moral warning system.
“Conscience is the soul’s warning system.”
— John MacArthur, “Cauterizing the Conscience,” Grace to You, sermon 80-235
MacArthur’s further point is crucial: conscience works from a person’s belief system. Feed it a false moral framework, and it will dutifully approve what it should condemn. An ideology that teaches that men as a class are oppressors, and that oppressors deserve no place, will produce consciences that feel righteous while contemplating the end of their own sons. That is why the remedy is not merely outrage but truth—the conscience must be re-informed by the Word of God.
Naming It Rightly
Is it fair to call such statements evil? Scripture does not hesitate to use the word. To wish innocent children out of existence because of their sex is to set oneself against the Creator who “created man in his own image… male and female created he them” (Genesis 1:27, KJV), and who knits each child together in the womb (Psalm 139:13–16). By the Bible’s own categories, the reported posts express a moral evil, and Christian writers need not soften that verdict.
But the same doctrine that names the evil forbids us to imagine that it lives only in others. Total depravity is not a weapon to aim at opponents; it is a mirror. Piper’s line is about “men”—all of us. Paul called himself the chief of sinners, a former persecutor who had consented to the death of the innocent Stephen (Acts 8:1; 1 Timothy 1:15). Nor should we mistake one woman’s posts for the views of the millions of Americans who share her politics; most of them, of every persuasion, would recoil at the idea of aborting sons. Paul reminds us that “we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world” (Ephesians 6:12, KJV). Our quarrel is with the darkness and the ideology that serves it. The woman herself is a sinner for whom Christ died, and she is not beyond the reach of the grace that turned Saul into Paul.
❧ ✦ ❧
The Ideology Behind the Words
Collective Guilt and the War of the Sexes
The reported posts did not appear in a vacuum. They are an extreme expression of a strand of contemporary thought that sorts human beings into oppressor and oppressed classes and assigns moral worth by group membership. In its most radical form, “patriarchy” ceases to describe particular injustices that men have committed and becomes a property of maleness itself. Once that move is made, the boy in the womb is guilty before his first breath, and the logic of elimination follows.
The gospel cuts across this sorting entirely. Male and female are created together in God’s image, both are fallen together in Adam, and both are redeemed on the same terms: “There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus” (Galatians 3:28, KJV). Christianity does not deny that men have sinned against women; Scripture records such sins without flinching and condemns them. But it locates guilt in persons and deeds, not in chromosomes, and it offers forgiveness rather than extermination as the answer to sin.
Children as Gift, Not Threat
Against the view that sons are a menace, the Psalmist sings: “Lo, children are an heritage of the LORD: and the fruit of the womb is his reward” (Psalm 127:3, KJV). The Lord Jesus, rebuking disciples who thought children a nuisance, said, “Suffer the little children to come unto me, and forbid them not: for of such is the kingdom of God” (Mark 10:14, KJV). The Child whom Herod sought to kill was Himself a boy—the male child of Revelation 12:5 who would rule the nations. Every Christmas, the Church celebrates the birth of a son as the best news the world has ever received.
❧ ✦ ❧
Biblical Admonitions: Exposing and Resisting the Darkness
Expose the Works of Darkness
“Take no part in the unfruitful works of darkness, but instead expose them.”
— Ephesians 5:11 (ESV), via OpenBible.info, “Exposing Evil”
Some believers read the next verse—“it is shameful even to speak of the things that they do in secret”—as a reason for silence. Bill Muehlenberg answers that verse 12 cannot cancel verse 11: light exposes darkness simply by shining, and that exposure can lead others to Christ. He also counsels discernment, refusing salacious detail while refusing to look away from moral decay.
“We are to call out evil while not being contaminated by it.”
— Bill Muehlenberg, “On Exposing Darkness and Evil,” CultureWatch, September 30, 2022
Stay Awake in Evil Days
Paul tells the Ephesians to walk circumspectly, “redeeming the time, because the days are evil” (Ephesians 5:15–16, KJV). Writing on that passage, I. Gordon warns against spiritual drowsiness and urges believers to stay alert and use every opportunity for God’s purposes. His summary is memorable: “Know the time, redeem the time and you’ll reap in time.” Christians who learn of statements like these should not merely shake their heads and scroll on. They should pray, speak, and act while the opportunity lasts.
Rescue Those Drawn Toward Death
“If thou forbear to deliver them that are drawn unto death, and those that are ready to be slain; if thou sayest, Behold, we knew it not; doth not he that pondereth the heart consider it?” (Proverbs 24:11–12, KJV). “Open thy mouth for the dumb in the cause of all such as are appointed to destruction” (Proverbs 31:8, KJV). The unborn, male and female alike, are the voiceless of our age. The Church must speak for them in the pulpit, in the public square, and through practical care for mothers who feel they cannot welcome a child.
Be Watchmen
God told Ezekiel that a watchman who sees the sword coming and does not blow the trumpet bears responsibility for the blood that follows (Ezekiel 33:6). Muehlenberg draws on these watchman passages to argue that warning others is part of the believer’s calling. In a matter touching children in a public school, that means parents and citizens may lawfully and respectfully ask the school district whether a teacher’s publicly expressed hostility toward boys affects the children in her care. It does not mean harassment, threats, or exposing her private life; those methods are works of darkness too.
Overcome Evil With Good
“Be not overcome of evil, but overcome evil with good” (Romans 12:21, KJV). The temptation, when confronted with contempt for our sons, is to answer contempt with contempt. Peter commands a better way: be ready to answer the hope within you “with meekness and fear” (1 Peter 3:15, KJV). The most powerful refutation of the claim that boys are a menace is a generation of Christian men who protect, serve, and lay down their lives for others as Christ did.
Proclaim Life to the Dead
Finally, the doctrine of spiritual death is not only a diagnosis; it is the backdrop for the best word in Scripture: “But God, who is rich in mercy, for his great love wherewith he loved us, even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ” (Ephesians 2:4–5, KJV). The same voice that called Lazarus from the tomb can call a hardened heart to life. Christians should pray for Dana Zentgraf by name—not for her humiliation but for her repentance and salvation—and for every person captured by an ideology that teaches them to fear their own children.
❧ ✦ ❧
Conclusion: The Child Herod Could Not Kill
Herod’s soldiers did their bloody work, and Rachel wept. But the one boy Herod most wanted dead was already on the road to Egypt, carried by a carpenter who had heeded an angel’s warning. Matthew notes that this, too, fulfilled Scripture: “Out of Egypt have I called my son” (Matthew 2:15; Hosea 11:1, KJV). Herod died within a few years, unmourned except by the decree he had arranged. The Child grew, went to a cross, and rose again, and He now holds the keys of death and of hell (Revelation 1:18).
The idea that sons are the enemy is not new. Pharaoh had it; Herod had it; the dragon of Revelation 12 has always had it. It surfaces again in each generation, sometimes with an army and sometimes with only a keyboard. The Church’s answer has not changed. We expose the darkness by naming it truthfully. We resist it by protecting the vulnerable and speaking for the voiceless. We refuse to become what we oppose. And we proclaim to everyone, including those who wish our sons had never been born, that a Son was given for them too—“and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace” (Isaiah 9:6, KJV). In Him, Rachel’s tears will one day be wiped away (Revelation 21:4).
Sources
Barton, Ethan. “‘We Need To Stop Giving Birth to Them’: Maryland Special Ed Teacher Called To Abort Boys, Overthrow US Government.” Washington Free Beacon, November 5, 2026. https://freebeacon.com/?p=2171393
Gordon, I. “Ephesians 5 Bible Study – Alert in Evil Days.” Jesus Plus Nothing. https://jesusplusnothing.com/series/post/ephesians-5-bible-study-alert-in-evil-days
GotQuestions.org. “What Was the Massacre of the Innocents?” https://www.gotquestions.org/Massacre-of-the-Innocents.html
GotQuestions.org. “What Is a Seared Conscience?” https://www.gotquestions.org/seared-conscience.html
Horn, Trent. “Is the Massacre of the Holy Innocents Historical?” Catholic Answers Magazine, December 26, 2019. https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/is-the-massacre-of-the-holy-innocents-historical
Josephus, Flavius. Antiquities of the Jews, Books 15–17.
Leslie, Wendyl. “Spiritually Dead.” Blogos. https://www.blogos.org/christianlifeandgrowth/spiritually-dead.php
Ligonier Ministries. “Total Moral Inability.” Tabletalk devotional. https://learn.ligonier.org/devotionals/total-moral-inability
MacArthur, John. “Cauterizing the Conscience.” Grace to You, sermon 80-235. https://www.gty.org/sermons/80-235/cauterizing-the-conscience
Maier, Paul L. “Truth or Fiction? Did Herod Really Slaughter Baby Boys in Bethlehem?” Desiring God (interview). https://www.desiringgod.org/interviews/truth-or-fiction-did-herod-really-slaughter-baby-boys-in-bethlehem
Monergism. “Dead in Sin: A Biblical Diagnosis of Spiritual Inability.” https://www.monergism.com/dead-sin-biblical-diagnosis-spiritual-inability
Muehlenberg, Bill. “On Exposing Darkness and Evil.” CultureWatch, September 30, 2022. https://billmuehlenberg.com/2022/09/30/on-exposing-darkness-and-evil/
OpenBible.info. “What Does the Bible Say About Exposing Evil?” https://www.openbible.info/topics/exposing_evil
Piper, John. “Total Depravity & Unconditional Election, Session 4.” Desiring God, March 8, 2008. https://www.desiringgod.org/messages/total-depravity-unconditional-election-session-4
Utter, Eric. “Special Education Teacher Says All Male Babies Should Be Aborted.” American Thinker, November 21, 2026. https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2026/11/special-education-teacher-says-all-male-babies-should-be-aborted/
Scripture quotations are from the King James Version unless marked ESV (English Standard Version).
Colophon: Researched and drafted with the assistance of Claude (Anthropic) as a scholarly research collaborator. The author retains full editorial authority over the final text.