An Essay in Historical and Literary Criticism I. The Room With No Curtain There was no curtain. That single fact, so easily lost in two centuries of argument, is where any serious inquiry into the Book of Mormon must begin. In the spring of 1829, in a farmhouse in Fayette, New York, a twenty-three-year-old man…
Category: Joseph Smith
HOW THE BOOK OF MORMON WAS COMPOSED: A Summary and Analysis of Mormon Stories Episode 1615
Claude AI summary of Mormon Stories podcast “How the Book of Mormon was Composed” Ep. 1615 Source Program: Mormon Stories Podcast, Episode 1615 — “How the Book of Mormon was Composed,” installment ten of the LDS Discussions series. Participants: John Dehlin (host); Mike of LDS Discussions (guest); Douglas Stilgoe, known online as “Nemo the Mormon”…
The LDS Word of Wisdom: A Revelation Examined from a Traditional Christian Perspective
The Revelation That Wasn’t a Commandment: How a Cup of Coffee Came to Guard the Gates of Mormon Heaven “But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you with meekness and fear.” —…
Render Unto Whom? Tithing, Trust, and the $300-Billion Question in Latter-day Saint Stewardship
LDS Vs Traditional Christianity – A study in comparative theology ❦ ❧ ❦ Introduction: A Tenth, a Temple, and a Trillion Dollars Few subjects reveal the distance between traditional Christianity and the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints as sharply as the doctrine of tithing. On the surface, the two traditions appear to agree:…
THE MORMON GODS OF MANY WORLDS: The Unresolved Contradiction at the Heart of Latter-day Saint Exaltation
A Theological Examination of Eternal Progression, Premortal Life, and the Eternal Presence of Heavenly Father I. Two Promises, One Soul: The Knot at the Center A faithful Latter-day Saint who has knelt at a sealing altar in a temple of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has been given two promises that, on…
Summary and Analysis: The Book of Mormon Verified (A. B. Phillips, 1912)
Bibliographic Context The pamphlet, No. 231 in the Herald Publishing House series (Lamoni, Iowa — then the RLDS headquarters), was written by Elder A. B. Phillips and printed in 1912. Phillips’s central thesis is that forty “eminent archaeologists and authors” had, by the early twentieth century, unwittingly confirmed the Book of Mormon’s narrative of ancient…
Conjured into Existence: Joseph Smith’s 1842 Temple Ordinances
Image: A digitally enhanced photo by this author of the Gilbert, Arizona LDS Temple. A Historical and Theological Examination of the Most Sacred Mormon Rituals ❦ ❦ ❦ Introduction: A Cathedral Built in Seven Weeks On the second floor of a modest mercantile building in Nauvoo, Illinois, on the warm morning of May 4, 1842,…
Eight Lines of Evidence, One Cumulative Conclusion: A Cold-Case Look at the Credibility of the Latter-day Saint Founder
Why the Entire Mormon Restoration Stands or Falls on One Man, Joseph Smith ❦ ❦ ❦ Introduction: The Hinge on Which Everything Else Turns There is a particular kind of theological conversation that, no matter where it begins, ends up in the same place. It may begin with the Book of Mormon. It may begin…
A 19th-Century Echo in an Ancient Voice: The Linguistic Fingerprints That Date the Book of Mormon
A scholarly examination of the Book of Mormon’s textual and literary fingerprints ❦ ❦ ❦ Introduction: A Book Worth Examining Honestly On the title page of every modern copy of the Book of Mormon, readers encounter a remarkable claim: that the volume in their hands is an authentic ancient record, translated by the gift and…
The LDS Living, Baptized for the Dead: One Verse, a Billion Names, and a Question of Authority
A Traditional Christian Examination of Latter-day Saint Proxy Baptism ✦ ⬩ ✦ Introduction: A Woman in the River On a September day in 1840, a widow named Jane Neyman waded into the muddy current of the Mississippi River near the half-built city of Nauvoo, Illinois. She was not being baptized for herself. She had come…








